Unrequited
Updated: Jul 8, 2018
In 1995 officials found more than 400 suitcases in an attic at what was once known as the Willard Asylum for the Chronic Insane. Dating from the1920s to the 1960s, the suitcases were cataloged and recorded, and eventually exhibited in the New York State Museum. Among these relics were the belongings of Mrs. Abigail Dewitt, a woman who was committed to the asylum in March of 1942. With permission from her family, excerpts from her diary tell the story of her final days and shed light on one of Syracuse’s oldest folk lores.

November 20, 1941
What a Thanksgiving this was! I truly cannot believe I am so incredibly blessed. Francis surprised me beyond words when after Thanksgiving dinner this evening, before his entire family, he proposed marriage. I of course said yes and now it is official, I am to become Mrs. Abigail Dewitt. Mrs. Francis Abigail Dewitt. I can hardly contain my joy!
Francis intends to follow in his brother’s footsteps and enlist in the Army so plans are to be made straight away for a Valentines Day wedding. The day is indeed befitting a love such as ours. I dare say that no one has loved one another as Francis and I do, and I dare say no one ever will.
December 12, 1941
I have been kept quite busy. My nursing studies have been undeniably demanding, expectedly so given the prestige of Syracuse University’s College of Medicine. What’s more is that all the while I’ve been so inundated with making the wedding arrangements. I’ve hardly had time at all to spend with Francis. And boy, what an endeavor this planning has become. We are unable to marry on Valentines Day if we still intend to hold the reception at the Hotel Syracuse. They have availability on the day before though, which will suite us just fine.
Some say it is a bad omen to marry on Friday the 13th, but I do not subscribe to such superstition. All will be very well. The winter break from school is a much needed reprieve and once I graduate in the Spring, I wish to also aid in the war. How serendipitous it would be if I were to be assigned to the same station as Francis. I could protect him and not have to miss him at all. Soon I will be comforted by the promise of an eternity together with my love.

January 13, 1942
My heart breaks for Franics. Today, when we were having lunch with his mother, two men in Army uniforms come to her house to tell her that his brother has perished in the war. The anguish and heartache that poor woman endures. She made him swear not to enlist unless forced by draft and in their moment of grieving, he gave her his word. I know this isn’t what he wants, but I can’t help feeling relieved that he will avoid suffering the same fate as his dearly departed brother. It’s one thing to be a nurse overseas in a well-protected hospital, but if my studies have imparted anything upon me, it’s that in this war, to enlist in the infantry is to gamble with your life. I couldn’t bear losing him just as our life together has begun.
February 12, 1942
Tomorrow is the day. Francis and I will finally be married and we can begin our journey together into the unknown. Things have been difficult for Francis. Now that he will not become soldier, he has taken a promotion at work. I am trying to get him to see the bright side of things, but he feels his place should be in the war. He wants to serve justice. I know he is still happy that we will be married, but his heart is broken for his brother. Tomorrow, when we say our vows, I know our love will warm the coldness that has taken hold in him. Tomorrow will be the first day of forever.

**********
Syracuse Herald American
February 20, 1942
Wedding night car crash leaves husband perished, wife hospitalized
SYRACUSE, N.Y. — Syracuse Police Department discovered newlyweds, Francis and Abigail Dewitt, on Cedarvale Road Saturday morning after having careened off the road on their wedding night. Francis was found dead on arrival and Abigail was discovered unconscious, yet still alive.
After colliding in to a guard rail, the Dewits were both ejected from the vehicle. Francis’ body was discovered in a tree 20 feet from the vehicle and Abigail was found in the creek that runs adjacent to the road commonly known as the 13 curve road.
Abigail remains in critical condition at the Hospital of the Good Shepard and services for Francis will be held at the Woodlawn Cemetery on February 26.

Syracuse Herald American
February 27, 1942
Syracuse bride wakes from two-week coma
Abigail Dewitt, a newly-wed bride whose husband, Francis Dewitt, died on their wedding night February 13 woke from a 14-day-long coma last night.
Doctors were originally unsure if Abigail would survive the horrific car wreck that hurtled her through the windshield of their vehicle and in to a creek in freezing temperatures. She was found the following morning unconscious, hypothermic and badly bleeding, still in her wedding dress. Francis’ body was found dangling in a tree not far from the wreck.
Abigail’s family have said they are very grateful that she is alive and now they are dedicated to ensuring she gets the help she needs so that she can be well.

**********
Willard Asylum for Chronic Insane
Initial patient assessment
March 2, 1942
Abigail Dewitt, 22 y/o, 5”3’, 130lbs
Patient was born in Syracuse, NY and has some college education with studies in nursing. She understands and speaks some German. She experienced a car accident whereafter she fell into a coma and her husband was deceased.
Upon admission patient was described as depressed, shaky, and fearful. During her initial intake interview she is neatly dressed, tense and intermittently disoriented. Her responses are relevant and she occasionally smiles appropriately. In general, however, her expression is sad and her attention is often drawn away from the present, requiring frequent re-direction toward the conversation at hand. She says, “I am never free of anxiety. The doctor says I must cooperate with the treatment, but I tend to fight them.” Patient occasionally insists that her late husband is still living and requests information regarding search efforts to find him. She also says that she has been fearful of harming hospital attendants who have tried to stop her from leaving the premises. This impulse began after regaining consciousness from a 14-day coma and being told of her husband’s death. She experiences significant night terrors and has been reported to sleep walk and shout her husbands name in her sleep. Some psychotic symptoms are evident.
Diagnosis: anxiety reaction with early onset psychosis.
Dr. Keil, K.

**********
March 7, 1942
They have insisted I return to journaling so that I can come to terms with my trauma. The trauma of losing Francis. Even writing the words down, it’s hard to believe. They may have seen him be buried, but I did not. What closure could I possibly incur without even seeing him one last time. The last thing I remember was the argument. Our silly squabble while driving on that damn road. He forbade me from nursing for the Army after I graduated and I was so persistent that I make my own choices. We were but a few hours wed and I was already a defiant wife. How foolish of me. How selfish. I’d give it all back to find him. This can’t be the way of it. It’s all wrong. They are all wrong.

March 12, 1942
I don’t trust them. Not a single one. They smile and play nice but I know they are conspiring against me. They want to keep me from my happiness. They are keeping me from Francis. They keep telling me he is gone and I have to accept it, but they are all filthily lairs. He’s out there. I know it. They just didn’t look hard enough. The thought of him out there, all alone, without me to love and protect him. We are destined for eternity and I am going to find him, if it’s the last thing l do.
**********
Willard Asylum for Chronic Insane
Incident Report
Friday, March 20, 1942
Re: Abigail Dewitt
At ~0830, Friday March 13, orderlies forcibly entered the patient’s room after she was reported absent from breakfast. The window was broken open and a substantial amount of blood was found on the glass. It is presumed that the patient broke the window, cut herself while exiting through it, and scaled down the three stories via a drain pipe on the exterior of the building. After a thorough search of the property, the authorities were informed at ~1400. To avoid panic, the police chief agreed to hold this information with the upmost sensitivity until the time the patient could be located. She is believed to be badly injured and wearing a white dressing gown. With temperatures below freezing that evening, the police and Willard Asylum staff congregated a search party to locate the patient. After seven days of searching, with no avail, it is believed that the Mrs. Dewitt has perished due to exposure.
**********
Abigail Dewitt had few family members at the time of her husband's death and her subsequent hospitalization. She made many attempts at escaping from Willard Asylum before she was successful on Friday the 13th in March of 1942, exactly one month after her husband died on their wedding night, also a Friday the 13th. Since 1942, there have been numerous reported sightings of the Phantom Bride on the 13 curves of Cedarvale Road. She is believed to be seen in a white dress, covered in blood and roaming the dangerous pass in search of her long lost husband.

Lauren Kurkimilis
Facebook forum: https://www.facebook.com/groups/2473344706225030/?source=create_flow
Tumblr photo story: http://lakurk.tumblr.com/post/170289150449
A fictional interpretation.




Comments